Because of the substantial chemical and dynamic differences between the stratosphere and the troposphere, individual atmospheric models have tended to focus on one or the other of the regions. This separation has worked well in addressing primarily stratospheric issues such as chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) and tropospheric issues such as regional pollution. Subsonic aircraft emissions, insofar as they are injected into the interface between the two atmospheric regions, present a particularly complex modeling challenge. To date, almost all model studies of subsonic aircraft NOx effects have been conducted with models that emphasize tropospheric chemistry; few contain an explicit representation of stratospheric chemistry. Most of the following discussion will center on those efforts. However, two models of the stratosphere-the Atmospheric Environmental Research (AER) and Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO) models used in Chapter 4-have calculated stratospheric ozone responses to 1992 subsonic fleet emissions of NOx. We discuss these results in Section 18.104.22.168 and use them in conjunction with the tropospheric model results to arrive at a total atmospheric impact of NOx emissions from present subsonic aviation.
Figure 2-3: Maximum percentage increase in ozone concentrations, in principal traffic areas, in the 9- to 13-km altitude range, 30-60�N latitude range, during summer, normalized by assumed global aircraft NOx emission to 0.5 Tg N yr-1 and plotted against the year the calculation was performed.
Recognition of the importance of heterogeneous chemical processes has increased steadily over the past 10 years; all atmospheric models now contain at least some of the gas-surface interactions identified in laboratory studies. However, relatively few global atmospheric models represent aerosol microphysics in a way that allows for simulation of the impacts of aircraft aerosols on atmospheric particle densities and surface areas. As a consequence, there has not yet been much effort directed at modeling the effects of aircraft particle emissions on atmospheric ozone. We evaluate one such study in Section 22.214.171.124.
Model studies of the impact of NOx emissions from aviation on ozone levels in the UT and LS have been performed with increasing sophistication since the 1970s. Most studies set up a base case without aircraft NOx emissions and a perturbed case with the aircraft source added. Differences in atmospheric composition and, ultimately, radiative forcing between the two cases are attributed to the influence of aircraft emissions. There are detailed differences among the many model studies that arise because of differences in the aircraft emission inventories employed. There are, however, many other more crucial differences in the model studies: The extent and accuracy of the treatment of atmospheric chemistry processes; the treatment of other NOx sources besides aircraft; the treatment of dispersion, transport, and advection of NOx species; and the adequacy of the treatment of the underpinning description of the coupled chemistry and the global atmospheric circulation in the UT and LS.
Many of the model studies note that the bulk of aircraft NOx emissions from subsonic aviation occurs in an atmospheric region that is sensitive to these emissions. Because of low background NOx levels-typically 50-200 ppt-in the mid-latitude UT and LS, high NO/NO2 ratios, and low HOx concentrations, ozone production (in terms of ozone molecules) per NOx molecule is more efficient here than anywhere else in the atmosphere. Because the greenhouse blanketing produced by a given atmospheric ozone increment is directly proportional to the temperature contrast between radiation absorbed and radiation emitted, radiative forcing efficiency is greatest for ozone changes near the tropopause (Lacis et al., 1990), though its climate sensitivity may have a different response (Hansen et al., 1997).
Table 2-1: Calculated changes in ozone inprincipal traffic areas and 9- to 13-km region during summer for five selected models employed in Chapter 4 for the 1992 aircraft subsonic fleet NOx emissions of 0.5 Tg N yr-1(see Chapter 9), together with the range of previous studies shown in Figure 2-3.
In completing our assessment of ozone impacts from present subsonic aircraft NOx emissions, we have gathered results from 48 model studies, which are listed in the bibliography at the end of the chapter. In each case, the model results have been normalized by the assumed global aircraft NOx emission source strength and put on the common basis of 0.5 Tg N yr-1. There are, however, differences in the spatial distributions used in these inventories, and local NOx and ozone concentration impacts will not necessarily scale accurately with global emission source strength. Despite this important reservation, global emission source strength is a useful index in a first examination of the model results.
Based on these results, we conclude that subsonic aviation has impacts on atmospheric composition in the principal traffic areas at 9-13 km altitude, 30-60�N latitude, averaged over chemically significant time scales of up to a few days. These impacts may be summarized as follows for normalized NOx emissions of 0.5 Tg N yr-1:
Significant local increases in NOx levels, by up to hundreds of ppt
Significant local increases in ozone, by up to 12 ppb, over a region including air traffic corridors and polewards of them, averaged over available calculations for January and July
Ozone increases of 2-14%, at their maximum in July, downstream and extending to the north of principal traffic areas, reflecting the long atmospheric lifetime of ozone in the UT and LS
Ratios of ozone increments to NOx increments on the order of 100, reflecting the high efficiency of the ozone production cycle in the UT and LS
Globally averaged ozone inventory increases of 3-10 Tg, or 1-3%, up to an altitude of about 15 km
Increases in tropospheric hydroxyl radical inventories of 0.3-3% globally up to an altitude of about 15 km.
Despite improvements in the realism with which processes have been represented in the models, the increase in dimensionality from 2-D to 3-D has not been accompanied by a change in the likely magnitude of local NOx and ozone changes anticipated from aircraft NOx emissions, when normalized by the assumed aircraft NOx emission to 0.5 Tg N yr-1 (Figure 2-3).
The original 2-D (altitude-latitude) model studies of the tropospheric ozone impacts of subsonic NOx emissions are close to the (mean + 1xsd) line from the entire ensemble of studies. 2-D model estimates have declined steadily so that by 1992 they were close to the (mean - 1xsd) line. The original 1-D studies showed a large amount of scatter and have not been used extensively for assessment purposes for the past decade or so. 2-D channel (altitude-longitude) models have been applied to the aircraft assessment as an interim strategy prior to 3-D (altitude-latitude-longitude) model development. 2-D channel model results are toward the high end of the range of results.
3-D models have been employed increasingly from 1994 onward, with the results lying toward the low end of the overall spread of model results. 3-D model results still show a considerable amount of scatter, and there is no evidence that the move from 2-D to 3-D models or the selection of 3-D models in Chapter 4 has improved inter-model consistency or overall predictive confidence. Regardless of how 2-D model results compare with zonally averaged 3-D model results, a crucial advantage of 3-D models is that they can account for zonal asymmetries and, in principle, be evaluated more decisively against local observations. Consequently, more confidence can be gained in their predictive capabilities for aircraft assessments (see Sections 126.96.36.199 and 188.8.131.52).
Based on all model results compiled for this assessment, our estimate of the likely ozone increase at its maximum in the principal traffic areas-9-13 km altitude, 30-60°N latitude-from 1992 subsonic aviation and during summer is about 6%, or 8 ppb, for a global aircraft NOx emission of 0.5 Tg N yr-1 (1.65 Tg NOx as NO2 yr-1; see Chapter 9).
Chapter 4 focuses attention on the development of future scenarios for subsonic aircraft NOx emissions; six 3-D global models have been employed to assess future impacts of subsonic aircraft. Table 2-1 shows ozone changes calculated in some of these models for 1992 subsonic operations compared with model results presented in previous studies. The latest model results in Table 2-1 appear to lie well within the central range of estimates from previous studies.
The estimates in Table 2-1 can be compared with previous assessments of the likely ozone impacts of NOx emissions from present aviation. The WMO-UNEP (1995) assessment described model results available to the end of 1993 as preliminary and indicative of maximum ozone increases of 4-12% at around 10 km for 30-50�N. The above estimates encompass a narrower range than that given in the WMO-UNEP (1995) assessment and suggest that the true value is at the lower end of previous estimates. An assessment prepared for the European Commission (Brasseur et al., 1998) concluded that the current fleet of commercial aircraft should have increased NOx abundances by 50-100 ppt near 200 hPa, with a corresponding increase in ozone concentrations of 5-9 ppb (i.e., 4-8%), during summertime. This latter range is consistent with the range identified in the present study, based on the five selected 3-D models.
|Figure 2-4: Estimate of mean trend using all four measurement systems (i.e., Umkehr, ozonesondes, SBUV, and SAGE I/II) at northern mid-latitudes (heavy solid line). Combined uncertainties are also shown as 1s (light solid lines) and 2s (dashed lines). Combined trends and uncertainties are extended down to 10 km as shown by the light dotted lines. The results below 15 km are a mixture of tropospheric and stratospheric trends, and the exact numbers should be viewed with caution. Combined trends have not been extended lower into the troposphere because the small sample of sonde stations have an additional unquantified uncertainty concerning their representativeness of mean trends (WMO, 1998).|
2-D models have been developed extensively over the past decade in response to the need for credible predictions of CFC impacts on stratospheric ozone and more recently for understanding the effects of future supersonic (high speed civil transport, or HSCT) aircraft fleets. Emphasis in these models has been placed on ClOx, HOx, and NOx chemistry in the 20-40 km region of the atmosphere, where the CFC and HSCT effects are expected to be manifested. Model calculations for the 1992 subsonic aircraft fleet have been performed by the AER and CSIRO 2-D models, described in detail in Chapter 4. For these calculations, the models have used the approach described in Section 184.108.40.206; namely, they have set up a base case without aircraft NOx emissions and a perturbed case with the aircraft source added. They also have both used the subsonic fleet emission inventory described in Chapter 9. The results of the two studies are in close agreement and yield the following conclusions:
Approximately 20% of subsonic emissions are released directly into the
stratosphere; this result is on the low end of empirically based estimates,
resulting in roughly a 1% increase in summertime NOx levels existing just
above the tropopause at 45�N latitude.
The aircraft-induced increase in lowermost stratospheric NOx causes an increase in ozone. Peak ozone increases are approximately 0.5% at northern mid-latitudes and at altitudes immediately above the tropopause. The total column ozone change resulting from stratospheric aircraft emissions is approximately 0.1%.
A very small amount of aircraft NOx is transported to altitudes above 22 km, where it acts to decrease ozone concentrations slightly.
A number of previous model studies have examined the effects of HSCT sulfate aerosols on stratospheric chemistry; several new studies are discussed in Chapter 4. A key uncertainty in these calculations has been the degree to which emitted sulfur forms submicron sulfate particles in the aircraft plume (see Section 3.2.3). As part of the Chapter 4 studies, the AER and UNIVAQ stratospheric models have calculated the response of stratospheric ozone to the subsonic fleet (year 2015) for a range of assumed SO2-to-particle conversion efficiencies. Details of those studies appear in Section 220.127.116.11. A rough estimate of the effect of sulfur emissions from the 1992 fleet can be made by scaling the 2015 results to 1992 emission levels. This calculation results in an estimate for the column ozone change at 45°N of approximately -0.1%.
The potential role of subsonic aircraft-generated soot in stratospheric ozone depletion has been investigated by Bekki (1997) using a 2-D model that includes heterogeneous reactions of HNO3, NO2, and ozone on soot. Using modeled aircraft soot aerosol distributions that were broadly consistent with observations, the model yields increased losses of ozone (approximately -0.2% column change at 45°N for the 1992 fleet) relative to the same model without soot chemistry. Moreover, inclusion of soot chemistry improves model agreement with the observed trend in LS ozone depletion. However, recent laboratory measurements indicating that soot is a reaction consumable do not support a major assumption of the Bekki model that soot acts as a catalyst.
|Figure 2-5: Annual trends for the periods 1970-96 and 1980-96 shown by ozonesonde measurements at Hohenpeissenberg, Germany. 95% confidence limits are shown [adapted from WMO (1998) by J. Logan].|
The degree to which soot consumption affects the Bekki calculations can be estimated as follows: If the heterogeneous reaction between ozone and soot proceeds at the highest reported rate (the one used in the Bekki calculation), namely g(O3) = 3.0 x 10-4 (Stephens et al., 1986; Fendel et al., 1995; Rogaski et al., 1997), the time required to consume the mass of soot present in the stratosphere would be approximately 10 minutes. It is important to note that this result is independent of the soot surface-to-volume ratio; it depends only upon the ozone concentration, which is taken to be 1011 cm-3 at 10-km altitude. At this reaction rate, only 5 hours would be required to consume the entire soot particulate population at 10 km (assuming 5 x 107 carbon atoms cm-3 at a soot loading of 1 ng m-3) and cause the effective soot-ozone reaction rate to drop to zero.
Laboratory evidence suggests that the soot-ozone reaction rate decreases after consumption and alteration of the top surface carbon layer (Stephens et al., 1986). Small reported laboratory g values-on the order of 3.0 x 10-5-likely reflect the reaction rate associated with a "deactivated" laboratory soot surface. Using this value for g, the time required to consume individual particles of soot would be less than a day, and the time to consume all atmospheric soot would be lengthened to approximately 3 weeks. Although this change in reaction rate extends the lifetime of atmospheric soot, it comes at the expense of the overall ozone destruction rate. Accordingly, our analysis indicates that the massof soot in the UT and LS does not seem to be sufficient to quantitatively affect ozone, regardless of the reaction rate chosen.
In support of this conclusion, we note that in situ measurements in the engine exhaust of a Concorde supersonic aircraft in the LS have been used recently to constrain heterogeneous reaction rates on soot particles in a plume model (Gao et al., 1998). Gao et al. inferred low reactivity for the ozone-soot interaction; coupled with the measured abundance of the soot aerosol, Gao et al. reach the same conclusion that we derived from our qualititative arguments. In summary, the few model calculations performed suggest that subsonic aircraft sulfate and soot emissions in the stratosphere act as substrates for ozone depletion. The magnitude of the depletions is likely to be small relative to ozone increases from NOx emissions, but the depletions are highly uncertain because of the poorstate of understanding and model development relative to aerosol chemistry.
Other reports in this collection